1) Bibliographic Data
Levitt, Peggy and Rafael de la Dehesa (2003) "Transnational Migration
and the Redefinition of the State: Variations and Explanations”,
Ethnic and Racial Studies, V.26- 4, July:587-611
2) Question(s) addressed by the author and working arguments
The authors seek to examine the shifting policies of sending country
states towards communities living abroad, demonstrate the ways in which
these are redefining the relationship between the state and its territorial
boundaries, and highlights how these reconfigure conventional understandings
of sovereignty, citizenship and membership. More and more states are
creating economic, political, and social mechanisms that enable migrants
to participate in the national development process over the long term
and from afar.
The authors categorize a set of possible policies:(1)Ministerial or
consular reforms, (2) investment policies which seek to attract or
channel migrant
remittances , (3) extension of political rights in the form of dual citizenship,
dual nationality, the right to vote abroad, or to run to public office,
(4) Extension of state protection or services abroad that go beyond traditional
consular services (5) Implementation of symbolic policies deigned to
reinforce immigrants’ sense of enduring membership
Some of the policies of sending states converge while others diverge
Why?
i) Explanations for Convergence: Structural imperatives facing developing
nations and the emergence of international norms
Developing nations need foreign exchange, so they implement policies
seeking to attract and channel remittances. To keep emigrants in their
court, as a way to ensure the continuance of these money flows, sending
states implement policies such as burocratic reforms or the extension
of voting rights
Developing nations also needs to bring relations with trade partners
closer, and emigrant communities are potential ambassadors who can foster
political and economic relations
New International norms have incorporated the idea of incorporation of
emigrant communities as citizenships with rights and duties as a trend
toward deeper democratization and as a natural outgrowth of globalization.
ii) Explanations for divergence: These factors are found in the national
level
Economical costs of particular policies.
The political cost-benefit calculations for different kinds of political
actors, such as Political Parties.
Ideological Profile of Political Parties.
3) Conceptual references to transnational-transnationalism
Transnational Public Sphere: The one which enables some emigrants to
participate politically, socially and culturally in two polities
4) Conclusions or Final Remarks
The authors suggested that the different sort of policies that states
implement might be attributed to the costliness of such policies and
the capacity of states to cover such costs and to the intervening role
of Political Parties, which also extend national political arenas to
emigrant communities and can channel demands back home.
They also try to explore the ways in which institutional structures-specifically
the state and the Political Parties- might encourage or perhaps impede
the construction of a transnational public sphere which enables some
emigrants to participate politically, socially and culturally in two
polities. They conclude suggesting that emigrants respond to their institutional
settings. In all cases studied, opportunities have given rise to, at
least, an immigrant elite interested in participating in home countries
politics. In cases where political parties are more active, participation
seems to spread to the border community.
|