1) Bibliographic data
Portes,
Alejandro; Luis E. Guarnizo; Patricia Landolt (1999) “The
Study of Transnationalism: Pitfalls and Promise of an Emergent
Research Field. Introduction to a Special Issue,” Ethnic
and Racial Studies V. 22 no2 Mar:217-37.
2) Question(s) addressed by the author and working arguments
The event in question pertains to the creation of a transnational community
linking immigrant groups in the advanced countries with their respective
sending nations and hometowns. Transnational entrepreneurs are depicted
as a new and still exceptional breed, whereas in others all immigrants
are said to be participants in the transnational communities.
In the case of transnationalism, it is not enough to invoke anecdotes
of some immigrants investing in business back home or some governments
giving their expatriates the right to vote in national elections to justify
a new field of study. To establish the phenomenon, at least three conditions
are necessary: (1) significant proportion of persons in the relevant
universe. (2) the activities of interest are not fleeting or exceptional,
but posses certain stability and resilience over time. (3) the content
of these activities is not captured by some pre-existing concept, making
the invention of a new term redundant. The ready availability of air
transport, long-distance telephone, facsimile communication, and electronic
mail provides the technological basis for the emergence of transnationalism
on a mass scale.
Two forms of transnationalism: (1) theoretical, because it represents
a distinct form of immigrant adaptation to those described in the past
literature, and (2) Practical, because it offers an option to ordinary
people not present in the past, either in their own countries or in those
to which they migrate.
3)
Conceptual references to transnational – transnationalism
Contemporary transnationalism corresponds to a different period in the
evolution of the world economy and to a different set of responses
and strategies by people in a condition of disadvantage to its dominant
logic.
4) Conclusions or Final Remarks
Transnational migration studies form a highly fragmented, emergent field
which still lacks both a well-defined theoretical framework and analytical
rigour.
|